Sunnu Rebecca Choi for NPR
Are you on the lookout for an sincere reply to a medical query? Dr. Mara Gordon, a household doctor in Camden, N.J., solutions reader well being questions month-to-month. Write us at: [email protected].
Query: I am sick of listening to about my weight once I go to the physician. I’ve heard that physique mass index is not even that useful in figuring out how wholesome I’m, however my physician nonetheless zones in on my BMI. What different metrics ought to my physician and I be utilizing to evaluate my well being?
Sadly, it is fairly widespread to satisfy docs who nag you about your weight.
As an anti-diet main care physician who takes a size-inclusive method with my very own sufferers, I typically hear from individuals who really feel belittled and shamed by this slim give attention to their physique measurement.
“Each single time I might go into the physician’s workplace, it was: ‘She’s obese,'” Jessi Rice Greenlow advised me. “‘It’s essential to get her into sports activities. It’s essential to cut back her meals.'”
Now Greenlow is a well being coach who helps households navigate weight stigma. However as a baby, Greenlow mentioned, each physician’s appointment became a dialogue about making her smaller.
“That formed what our dwelling life appeared like and what I used to be allowed to consider myself,” Greenlow mentioned.
Fortunately, there are many different science-backed metrics you may give attention to as a substitute. In reality, BMI has some critical limitations in relation to assessing how wholesome you’re.
Once I work with my very own main care sufferers, I discover that specializing in extra evidence-based metrics — together with blood strain, glucose tolerance, mobility, and temper — is way much less stigmatizing. And it is extra scientific, too.
Listed here are some dialog starters you should use to nudge your physician into having a extra useful dialog — and the important thing well being metrics and objectives I might encourage you to give attention to as a substitute of your weight.
Know that BMI has limitations
In 2025, the Lancet revealed a serious report on weight problems, and the very first line acknowledges that BMI offers “insufficient details about well being on the particular person stage.”
BMI might be helpful for monitoring population-wide tendencies about physique measurement, but it surely’s typically too blunt of an instrument to offer you actionable details about your personal well-being.
That is why in 2023, the American Medical Affiliation handed a decision noting that BMI has “vital limitations” when utilized in medical observe.
Daily in my very own clinic, for instance, I take care of sufferers who’ve a so-called “regular weight” who’ve superior diabetes and heart problems. Then, my very subsequent affected person is perhaps energetic and thriving with a BMI within the weight problems vary, with no proof of coronary heart illness or diabetes.
And weight reduction is not all the time constructive. Another person with a supposedly regular BMI might need misplaced weight due to most cancers therapy.
You’ll be able to skip the dimensions
You do not have to be weighed at each physician’s appointment. Whereas many practices embody weight as a part of their routine workflow, that does not imply you need to do it. A well mannered refusal — “I might choose to not be weighed” — is usually all it takes.
Generally docs do want correct weights to handle sure medical circumstances. Chemotherapy dosing might be weight-dependent, for instance, and there are coronary heart circumstances delicate to minor fluctuations in fluid ranges, which might be caught early by correct weight measurement.
I additionally prefer to know if my sufferers expertise a speedy weight reduction or weight achieve, which might be indicators of underlying medical issues. For in any other case wholesome folks, I often prefer to get an up to date weight not less than annually.
Your physician needs to be keen to clarify why they should measure your weight. In the event that they really want to however you discover it distressing, you may ask the medical assistant to not disclose the quantity.
Push for the dialog you need
In case your physician initiates a dialogue about weight that does not really feel welcome, Greenlow prompt having what she calls “pocket phrases” prepared to show the dialog in the direction of these different well being metrics and habits.
“Observe beforehand,” Greenlow mentioned. “If you go into the workplace blind, that may be form of difficult, and also you may freeze up.”
Listed here are just a few of the phrases she’s used with docs:
“I am not snug speaking about my weight each appointment.”
“What else can we speak about?” or “What different exams can be found that might be successful marker?”
Most docs, I hope, can be comfortable to broaden the dialog past physique measurement.
Focus in your well being objectives, not your measurement
When my very own sufferers are available for a checkup, I often like to start out with this query: “What are your objectives?” What it means to be “wholesome” is completely different for each affected person, so I attempt to take the time to discover what a full, flourishing life appears to be like like for them.
For instance, lots of my sufferers need to add extra greens to their eating regimen and reduce on ultraprocessed meals. That is typically an ideal plan to really feel good and cut back the chance of cardiometabolic illness. However for an individual in restoration from an consuming dysfunction, focusing an excessive amount of on eating regimen might be psychologically distressing. It is perhaps more healthy for that affected person to take a break from worrying about meals.
And your well being objectives can change over your lifetime. Train could also be actually difficult in the event you’re caring for a younger youngster, and sleep will take precedence. However within the menopausal transition, train could also be your prime aim in the event you’re seeking to stop bone loss.
Greenlow mentioned she lately began seeing a health care provider who asks her questions on her well being objectives and the habits she needs to work on, relatively than merely telling her to drop a few pounds.
“For any individual who considered measurement as being synonymous with well being … it is a new psychological mindset to permit your self to see wins away from the dimensions,” Greenlow mentioned. For her that features a give attention to getting higher sleep so she has “secure power all through the day.”
Listed here are just a few key objectives and habits to debate together with your physician:
Psychological well being:
As I work with my sufferers to outline their well being objectives, psychological well being is a vital part. It is typically difficult for folks to consider their bodily wellbeing with out the muse of a constructive temper.
That is why most main care docs display their sufferers for melancholy. Should you’ve been feeling down, do not hesitate to ask your physician about therapy choices. There are excellent therapies for melancholy — remedy and drugs can work wonders! — and I do not need to miss a chance to assist my sufferers. One other query price contemplating is how typically you see the folks you like, since there is a large physique of proof that reveals sturdy social connections may help stop illness and early demise.
Motion:
It is no secret that common train is nice for every part from bettering your temper to defending your bones — and even a little bit goes a great distance! I prefer to reframe train not as punishing 3-hour gymnasium periods however relatively as little motion “snacks” that may slot in all through your day, issues like gardening or a every day stroll with a pal.
After all, mobility generally is a problem and also you should not really feel unhealthy when you have mobility limitations. If that is your scenario, ask your physician about assistive units like canes, walkers, and wheelchairs which may help folks do what they need to do.
Sleep:
Sleep is the muse of every part! It’s vital for each bodily and psychological well being. I attempt to test in about sleep habits and discover out if my sufferers are struggling. If you’re, ask your physician about evidence-based therapies. Cognitive behavioral remedy for insomnia may be very efficient and medication-free!
Metrics to observe: glucose tolerance
I check most of my sufferers for indicators of glucose intolerance, which generally is a precursor to diabetes. That is often accomplished by checking a glucose check or a Hemoglobin A1C. I choose the A1C as a result of it may be accomplished with out fasting, which makes it a lot simpler for my sufferers to get it accomplished.
It offers my sufferers and I a way of what their blood sugar ranges have been over the previous few months. A analysis of diabetes – that is an A1C of 6.5 or above – warrants therapy immediately to stop issues. When you’ve got an elevated A1C with out being on the diabetes stage (also called pre-diabetes) that is typically a great cause to give attention to common train. Every day strolling may help stop prediabetes from progressing to diabetes, even in the event you do not drop a few pounds doing it.
Perceive your heart problems threat
Understanding your threat for growing heart problems — after which lowering that threat, by way of eating regimen, train, and drugs — is a key a part of wellness.
Historically, most main care docs have estimated that threat utilizing a calculator known as the Pooled Cohort Equations, generally identified to docs because the Athersclerotic Cardiovascular Illness Danger Estimator. It appears to be like on the components that put sufferers in danger for coronary heart illness and stroke. The American Coronary heart Affiliation recommends that folks often begin a ldl cholesterol medication known as a statin if their 10-year threat of a coronary heart assault or stroke is 7.5% or above.
However now there is a new calculator on the town: the PREVENT calculator, which many docs are actually turning to as a result of it was developed utilizing extra knowledge and can be utilized for youthful folks. Analysis suggests it is a greater device to estimate threat, although it hasn’t but been formally adopted by the AHA tips about statin use.
In case your physician recommends treatment based mostly on a threat calculator, it is price speaking to them about which calculator they used and which variables it contains.
One other device I typically suggest to estimate threat of coronary heart illness known as coronary calcium scoring, a CT scan of the guts that measures calcified plaque within the arteries of your coronary heart. In case your LDL ldl cholesterol (the “unhealthy ldl cholesterol”) is elevated however you do not fairly meet standards to start out a drugs, a coronary calcium rating may help consider in the event you may profit or not.
Keep on prime of most cancers screening
Ensure you’re up-to-date on the most cancers screening that is really useful on your age. Discuss to your physician concerning the specifics of your medical historical past and household historical past, however the massive ones are as follows: cervical most cancers for anybody with a uterus, breast most cancers screening for ladies and colon most cancers screening for most individuals beginning at age 45.
Dr. Mara Gordon is a household doctor in Camden, N.J.. She writes the Substack publication “Your Physician Buddy.”
