State collaboration on public health messaging could build trust : NPR

ARI SHAPIRO, HOST:

The tip of summer season is often the time of yr when docs and pharmacists begin to counsel vaccinations for viruses like flu and COVID primarily based on federal suggestions. However this yr’s very completely different. With Robert F. Kennedy Jr. main the Division of Well being and Human Companies, the method and steering have modified considerably, over the objections of many docs and epidemiologists. Now some state public well being officers are contemplating how they could collaborate to difficulty their very own public well being steering. Dr. Robbie Goldstein is the commissioner of the Massachusetts Division of Public Well being, and he is one of many leaders of that effort. Welcome to ALL THINGS CONSIDERED.

ROBBIE GOLDSTEIN: Thanks for having me.

SHAPIRO: What do you make of the adjustments to the CDC’s vaccine suggestions this yr?

GOLDSTEIN: Yeah, I believe thus far, what we have seen out of CDC is minor adjustments that they’ve been making all through the summer season, however they’re including as much as fairly vital adjustments to our vaccine coverage right here in America. I believe particularly what we have seen is a direct assault on a few of the kinds of vaccines that we use on this nation, together with mRNA vaccines, and particular illnesses that we all know are necessary to guard in opposition to, however but are being known as into query by the present federal administration. Specifically, I wish to name out COVID-19.

SHAPIRO: And in order that’s one of many causes that you just pulled collectively this group of public well being leaders from throughout eight states within the Northeast to start out a dialog about potential collaboration. Clarify how that will work. How would this area difficulty public well being steering when the CDC has public well being steering which may battle with it?

GOLDSTEIN: I wish to first say that states have at all times historically put out their very own steering for their very own states, to ensure that the data that we’re sharing resonates with our communities and the those who stay in our states. So we’re not essentially doing something completely different this yr. What we’re doing is we’re coming collectively proactively, and we’re making a dedication to do that course of transparently and collectively. And we expect by doing so, we’ll assist construct belief within the suggestions that we put out, and we’ll additionally ensure that we’re defending as many individuals as potential throughout the Northeast.

SHAPIRO: That query of belief appears actually foundational right here. Do you run the danger of muddying the waters if, for instance, the CDC says, wholesome individuals over the age of 18 do not all have to get a brand new COVID shot, and but Massachusetts and 7 different states say, wholesome individuals over the age of 18 do have to get a COVID shot, to take a hypothetical?

GOLDSTEIN: Nicely, I believe belief is de facto constructed by means of dialog and thru transparency. And so if we within the Northeast come collectively and share our knowledge publicly, I do suppose we will construct belief, even when our suggestions are completely different than what we see out of the federal authorities. I additionally hope that what we’re doing right here within the Northeast is perhaps an instance that we may set for others throughout the nation, and definitely for the federal authorities, about how they will use knowledge and the way they will current these knowledge transparently of their decision-making course of.

SHAPIRO: Does this finally result in a future the place you’ve got one set of well being insurance policies for purple states and one other for blue states, regardless of who’s in cost on the federal stage? – ‘trigger you may think about a situation the place a Democratic HHS secretary endorses a vaccine that public well being appointees in Texas or Florida may oppose.

GOLDSTEIN: Nicely, I definitely hope that does not occur, and that’s not our intention with the Northeast collaborative. I am going to notice for people that within the Northeast we’ve Democrats and Republicans, together with Democratic and Republican governors and state legislators. We’re coming collectively not primarily based on partisan politics, however we’re coming collectively quite due to science and proof.

SHAPIRO: I do know you stated this isn’t political, however for thus many many years Democrats have stated, the federal authorities is appearing in your finest pursuits, whereas Republicans have stated, take heed to us on the state stage. It actually does look like the tables have turned – that you just’re now saying, individuals should not essentially belief the federal authorities’s steering. Belief us, the state appointees, as an alternative.

GOLDSTEIN: It might really feel that method, however a lot has modified prior to now 9 months that this looks like a necessity. It feels as if we’ve to shift on this method. The explanation that traditionally Democrats could have pointed to the federal authorities and to the steering is that we may consider in that steering. We knew that that steering, these suggestions, had been primarily based the truth is. That is simply not the case now. We oftentimes see choices being made by a tweet or a submit on Fact Social, choices in public well being being made by a video posted to YouTube. That is not the system that we have existed in earlier than, and so it requires us to vary our ways.

SHAPIRO: What’s at stake? What are the dangers right here?

GOLDSTEIN: I believe, , if we do not depend on the proof, if we do not use knowledge to drive our choices, we’ll see individuals get sick. We’ll see the well being of our communities fail. We’ll see our hospitals fill with individuals who have vaccine-preventable illnesses. And I do not suppose we’ve to look too far into the longer term to see that. If we have a look simply this previous yr at what occurred in West Texas with a measles outbreak spreading to many different states within the area and different nations, that is what occurs after we do not use proof and knowledge to drive the advice. Within the case of measles, we all know that the measles vaccine is protected and efficient, however that message did not come clearly from the federal authorities.

SHAPIRO: Dr. Robbie Goldstein is commissioner of the Massachusetts Division of Public Well being. Thanks very a lot.

GOLDSTEIN: Thanks a lot for having me.

Copyright © 2025 NPR. All rights reserved. Go to our web site phrases of use and permissions pages at www.npr.org for additional info.

Accuracy and availability of NPR transcripts could fluctuate. Transcript textual content could also be revised to right errors or match updates to audio. Audio on npr.org could also be edited after its authentic broadcast or publication. The authoritative document of NPR’s programming is the audio document.