There’s a time-honored disaster administration technique, whereby one says nothing and waits for the outrage to cross. For Sequoia Capital, the technique labored fairly properly this week. Whereas companion Shaun Maguire initially weathered criticism over an inflammatory social media publish, that preliminary indignation cooled shortly. Now, some appear to suppose that Maguire’s defiant stance could even be strengthening his place. Enterprise Insider really referred to as it “good for deal circulate” — controversy as aggressive benefit.
Sequoia’s calculated gamble carries actual threat, although. One other provocative publish from Maguire that hits the incorrect nerve, a shift in political winds, or escalating penalties might shortly remodel their unflappable companion from an asset right into a legal responsibility the agency can not afford to disregard.
A disaster communications skilled who has managed repute disasters for dozens of main manufacturers tells this editor, “Companies like Sequoia are bulletproof till they aren’t.”
What occurred
Sequoia’s hands-off strategy was put to the take a look at earlier this week when the storied enterprise agency discovered itself within the eye of a storm over Maguire’s feedback about New York Metropolis mayoral candidate Zohran Mamdani. Maguire referred to as him an “Islamist” who “comes from a tradition that lies about every little thing” in a July 4th tweet on X that has since been considered greater than 5 million occasions. A couple of thousand signatures have poured in concerning a petition demanding that Sequoia condemn the remarks, examine Maguire’s conduct, and apologize.
There’s been lots of discuss why Sequoia hasn’t accomplished this, with many shops noting that Maguire isn’t simply any companion. This standing owes partly to his friendship with Stripe co-founder Patrick Collison. In keeping with studies, at a 2015 Founders Fund occasion, Maguire — then a Founders Fund-backed entrepreneur — defended Collison throughout an argument with Anduril’s Palmer Luckey about quantum computing, incomes Collison’s friendship. The connection proved useful when Maguire joined Google Ventures in 2016; he helped safe a $20 million Stripe funding throughout his first week. When Maguire left Google Ventures in 2019, Collison personally really helpful him to Sequoia’s companions. (Stripe has been in Sequoia’s portfolio since 2010, with the agency investing greater than $500 million over 15 years.)
Maguire additionally led Sequoia’s funding in Bridge, a stablecoin platform that Stripe acquired for $1.1 billion, and is reportedly Sequoia’s hyperlink to Elon Musk, although he’s hardly its solely hyperlink. Musk and Sequoia’s international chief, Roelof Botha, are each native South Africans and have identified one another for greater than 25 years, courting again to their time collectively on the then-nascent PayPal, the place Botha was recruited personally by Musk.
Regardless of that lengthy relationship, the 2 haven’t all the time seen eye to eye. Botha was extremely important of Musk’s administration type when Musk was CEO of the merged X.com/PayPal firm, the place Botha was CFO. Botha as soon as instructed veteran journalist Ebbe Dommisse, “I believe it might have killed the corporate if Elon had stayed on as CEO for six extra months. The errors Elon was making on the time had been amplifying the danger of the enterprise.” However Musk was at odds with just about that whole crew on the time, and people tensions have lengthy since been resolved.
The larger level right here: whenever you’re managing tens of billions of {dollars} in property and your agency’s repute rests on backing winners like Google, Stripe, and Nvidia, you don’t simply solid apart a rainmaker.
In the meantime, Maguire’s habits suggests he’s not backing down. After issuing a 30-minute video on X final weekend through which he apologized for offending so many — saying he was making a degree a couple of political ideology and never one a couple of faith — he has doubled down with more and more aggressive posts this week. He claimed he has “reverse engineered” his critics’ “command construction” and threatened to “embarrass” anybody who escalates in opposition to him. He added that that is him at “1% throttle” and warned folks to not “fuck w youngsters of the web.”
The silent remedy
Sequoia has precedent for its strategy to this case. The agency has traditionally given its companions house to precise themselves publicly, with figures like Doug Leone and Michael Moritz (who left the agency in 2023) representing totally different political views.
However there’s an important distinction between political range and incendiary rhetoric and clearly to some, Maguire’s feedback prolong past partisan politics into territory that alienates each political opponents and potential enterprise companions.
It’s additionally price remembering that even for Sequoia, there’s a shiny line. Michael Goguen, one other, earlier rainmaker with the agency, was promptly proven the door when Sequoia realized of a sexual abuse lawsuit filed in opposition to him. The conditions aren’t precisely comparable; Goguen’s points had been authorized and private, not ideological. On the similar time, Sequoia has proven it isn’t keen to circle the wagons at any value, not if its repute is at stake.
Presumably, a number of elements inform Sequoia’s do-nothing PR technique, together with how shortly folks, confronted with a continuing flurry of reports, transfer on from a scandal. The agency can be working in a unique political panorama proper now within the U.S. Together with Donald Trump’s victory and the rollback of DEI initiatives has come new tolerance for controversial speech. What may need been career-ending at an earlier time limit is now weathered extra simply.
Past the shifting political winds, the agency is probably going banking on the truth that whereas founders need companions who match the standard, extra genteel VC mould, they need profitable ones much more. Startups being courted by a number of top-tier corporations may not like or agree with Maguire, however when Sequoia comes calling with its observe file and nearly bottomless pockets, most founders are going to welcome the agency with open arms.
After all, there’s the very actual chance, too, that Sequoia is engaged on a contingency plan. (Sequoia declined to touch upon Maguire’s posts when reached by TechCrunch earlier this week.)
Nonetheless, Sequoia’s silence carries dangers. Not all of the signers have been confirmed, however the petition in opposition to Maguire consists of the names of some outstanding Center Japanese executives and founders who’ve attested to signing it, they usually signify the form of numerous, international expertise pool on which Sequoia’s future relies upon. By not addressing the controversy, Sequoia dangers being seen as tacitly endorsing Maguire’s views.
Put one other method, although the enterprise capital world has traditionally been remarkably forgiving of controversial figures with distinctive deal circulate, the agency is playing with its repute in an more and more related international market the place alienating whole areas and communities carries actual enterprise penalties.
Whether or not that guess pays off will rely on how lengthy the controversy lingers, how a lot enterprise it really prices Sequoia, and whether or not Maguire can resist the urge to push issues previous Sequoia’s personal tolerance threshold. (He has stated he doesn’t publish something that hasn’t been “excrutiatingly thought out.”)
Historical past means that established monetary corporations with sturdy observe data are inclined to outlive their scandals, even severe ones. When Apollo International Administration’s Leon Black resigned in 2021 over his $158 million funds to Jeffrey Epstein, the agency’s inventory barely moved and shareholders appeared largely unfazed. Apollo simply continued its aggressive deal-making below new management.
Equally, Kleiner Perkins survived Ellen Pao’s high-profile gender discrimination lawsuit in 2015. But it surely took years and primarily a completely new crew for the storied enterprise agency to regain its footing in Silicon Valley’s hierarchy. The lesson right here could also be that whereas controversial companions might be endured, the restoration timelines can differ considerably relying on how corporations deal with the disaster.
For now, the disaster communications skilled, who requested to not be named, has some recommendation for Maguire and, by extension, Sequoia. Relating to the video Maguire revealed within the aftermath of his preliminary feedback, the professional stated, “I did suppose that apology addressed the ambiguities in [Maguire’s] publish. But it surely’s a 30-minute video — you must be actually to look at this.”
If there’s a subsequent time, the skilled stated, Maguire ought to “do two movies — one for 3 minutes” and one other, longer video, for anybody who needs to maintain watching.
Generally, the professional added, “much less is extra.”
