No, Ukraine isn’t suffering 1,000 casualties per day

I’m a sucker for these sorts of movies: 

The enjoyment is actual, but tempered with the conclusion that quickly sufficient, their family members shall be again the worst hazard conceivable. I can’t watch for the ultimate celebration as soon as Russia is defeated, when households can lastly reunite for good.

However these movies additionally inform us one thing else: issues aren’t as dangerous for Ukraine as some have claimed. If Ukraine was shedding 300-1,000 troopers per day on the entrance strains, they wouldn’t be rotating models out and in. And whereas we don’t know the person tales at play right here, these aren’t damaged servicemembers. 

All week I’ve been skeptical of Ukrainian claims of mass casualties, studying them as propaganda ploys to maintain Western weapons flowing. Ukraine is. involved that Western consideration isn’t simply flagging, however may finally flip towards them over inflation, vitality availability, and different financial issues. Vitality shall be an actual European problem this winter, and the political proper is benefiting from the chaos—whether or not in France, the place the hard-right simply made large parliamentary features, or right here at residence, with Republicans salivating over November pickups. . 

Nonetheless, these fantastical Ukrainian claims simply by no means made a lot sense given the accessible proof. NASA FIRMS knowledge suggests that extra artillery is touchdown on Russian-held territory than Ukrainian. And certain, NASA FIRMS satellite tv for pc imagery isn’t excellent, however one would anticipate to see far better fireplace disparity if, certainly, Russia had a 10-1 benefit in artillery. Have a look at the final three days of fires close to Severodonetsk:

The overwhelming majority of these fires are on Russian-held territory. Those on Ukrainian land could be counted with one hand. Ukraine is slamming the f’ out of Russian artillery and logistical targets, and it appears comparable all across the Donbas entrance. Popasna, for instance, is getting smacked onerous. In the meantime, Russian accounts themselves have lamented their very own perceived incapacity to maintain up with Ukrainian artillery. 

In the meantime, if Ukraine was struggling as much as 1,000 casualties per day, how wouldn’t it have the flexibility to have interaction in counter-offensives round Kharkiv, Kherson, and Izyum? It’s clear that Ukraine has vital spare capability to wreak havoc throughout three different battlefronts. Now, all three of these counteroffensives are restricted in scope. Russia is simply too entrenched, the terrain is simply too uncovered to artillery defenses, and Ukraine doesn’t have the numbers to punch their means by way of. However they’re nibbling across the edges, forcing Russia to redirect reserves away from the Donbas to those different fronts, lest they lose extra hard-gained territory. 

This “we’re getting smacked onerous” narrative was additionally at odds with what Ukraine’s army command has been reporting. Certainly, the disparity between civilian and army Ukrainian management has been stark. Examine a presidential advisor to Ukraine’s army command talking of Western artillery donations:

Ukraine urgently must shift to longer-range and extra subtle Western programs, however these have solely just lately been dedicated, and in inadequate portions to match Russia’s immense firepower, he stated.

Vs:

It’s price noting, as an example, that the preliminary request of the Armed Forces relating to 155 mm artillery models has been 90% fulfilled by the Ministry of Defence.

Certainly, their MoD introduced that that they had 110% extra artillery shells now than in the beginning of the battle!

The ultimate straw was the disconnect between army bulletins of Russian casualties (100-250 per day), and that the majority hysterical Ukrainian declare of 1,000 casualties per day (together with 300 wounded). If this was true, then yeah, Russia can be doing a lot better than their battlefield progress would recommend. 

Finally, somebody in Ukraine’s excessive command realized that their more and more hysterical pronouncements weren’t an awesome look. 

And with this announcement, I can lastly lay this subject to relaxation. Ukraine doesn’t must exaggerate its casualties to get extra Western help and support. Fairly the other—folks like to again a winner. “Let’s boot Russia from all Ukrainian territory” is a successful narrative, one which even President Emmanuel Macron lastly adopted. 

None of this implies Ukraine isn’t struggling horrific losses. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy pegged them a couple of weeks in the past at 50-100 per day. That’s dangerous sufficient, there’s no must exaggerate for impact. We are able to see fairly clearly the loss of life Russia is raining on Ukraine. 

——–

In the meantime, nothing of substance has modified on the bottom since Mark’s final replace. This about sums up Sunday: 

Russia’s highest precedence goal, Severodonetsk, stays contested. The Institute for the Examine of Conflict concluded that, “preventing within the space has largely stalled and Russian forces are more and more unable to consolidate management of the town, even with artillery superiority.” Ukraine actually advantages from overlooking the town from the bluffs of Lysychansk throughout the Donets river, taking out artillery supporting the Russian advance, whereas raining mortar fireplace in Russian positions within the metropolis itself. 

And house-to-house fight, in a means we haven’t seen since Mariupol.