“I wished to avoid wasting a half million boys on our facet…. I by no means misplaced any sleep over my determination.”—Harry Truman, (quoted in Alfred Steinberg, The Man From Missouri (New York, 1962), p. 259)
It’s estimated that there have been 416,480 American navy deaths in WWII. Thus, what we’re invited to consider by Truman’s assertion that the atomic bombs saved 500,000 (or many extra) American lives is that, had the US invaded Japan, extra People would have died in such actions than in all of the theaters of WWII mixed. Additional, that previous to the bombs, Truman, Stimson, and Marshall would have accepted an invasion plan (as these of Honshu and Kyushu) had they really believed that 500,000 American deaths would have resulted, versus extra doubtless options previous to invasion.
The Bomb and Huge Fish Tales
Just like the tendency of “who-caught-the-biggest-fish” exaggerations to develop with every subsequent story, it appears that evidently the numbers of the American lives supposedly saved by the choice of the atomic bomb appears to develop with every retelling!
James B. Conant—desirous to get forward of the story—satisfied Secretary of Warfare Stimson to publish an article justifying using the bomb. Within the article in Harper’s (1947), it was claimed that the bomb most likely prevented “one million extra” American casualties. Nevertheless, in 1946, america Strategic Bombing Survey revealed the next evaluation,
Primarily based on an in depth investigation of all of the information and supported by the testimony of the surviving Japanese leaders concerned, it’s the Survey’s opinion that actually previous to 31 December 1945, and possibly previous to 1 November 1945, Japan would have surrendered even when the atomic bombs had not been dropped, even when Russia had not entered the struggle, and even when no invasion had been deliberate or contemplated. (emphasis added)
In gentle of this early post-war proof, it’s uncertain that such a defeated drive might have brought about 500,000 American deaths or extra. Shortly following Nagasaki, Churchill claimed that the bombings saved properly over 1,200,000 Allied lives. In 1953, Winston Churchill wrote, “To quell the Japanese resistance man by man and conquer the nation yard by yard would possibly properly require the lack of one million American lives and half that variety of British…” (emphasis added). This was based mostly on recollections of the Battle of Okinawa (65,631 casualties; 7,374 deaths), thus, nowhere close to 500,000 American deaths, not to mention “one million.”
Whereas within the White Home, Truman often positioned the variety of American lives saved round 250,000, and sometimes round 200,000. After leaving the White Home, Truman started upping the quantity to 300,000 lives within the first drafts of his memoirs. In 1955, Truman penned his Memoirs and, in quantity 1—Yr of Selections (1955)—he wrote, “Basic Marshall informed me that it may cost a little half one million American lives to drive the enemy’s give up on his dwelling grounds.” Truman additionally wrote a letter in 1953 that seems in The Military Air Drive in World Warfare II, Vol. 5, The Pacific, Matterhorn to Nagasaki, June, 1944-August, 1945, during which he said,
I requested Basic Marshall [at Potsdam] what it will value in lives to land on the Tokyo plain and different locations in Japan. It was his opinion that such an invasion would value at a minimal 1 / 4 of one million American casualties, and may cost a little as many as one million, with an equal variety of the enemy. The opposite navy males agreed. (emphasis added)
Be aware that Truman admits that Basic Marshall spoke of casualties, not deaths. Primarily based on the typical ratio of casualties to deaths within the Pacific, this could entail about 50,000-250,000 deaths, not the five hundred,000 Truman would later declare in 1955. For these and different causes, Barton J. Bernstein argues that, “The declare of half one million was a post-war creation.”
Though the declare of 500,000 American lives saved by the avoidance of invasion due to the atomic bomb was unwarranted, the counterfactual numbers of lives allegedly saved by the atomic bomb continued to develop. A sampling of secondary faculty textbooks reported that invasion, as an alternative of the bomb, might have brought about the lack of a million American lives. Within the Washington Put up (December 1, 1991), President George H. W. Bush claimed that the atomic bombs “spared hundreds of thousands of American lives.” Lastly, Tom Lewis wrote Atomic Salvation: How the A-Bomb Assaults Saved the Lives of 32 Million Individuals—described in a sympathetic assessment as assuming the dichotomy between atomic bomb or invasion with out different choices, as missing an index, restricted to solely English-language sources, primarily constructed off of secondary works, and utilizing major sources that present little perception into American decision-making—counting the overall lives saved—American, Japanese, and others.
Alternate options and Worst-Case State of affairs
Whereas such counterfactual claims of lives saved could seem believable given the viciousness of Pacific warfare, and whereas we must always not fault anybody for a unsuitable estimate typically, and whereas historical past should be honest to what was recognized on the time, the assured claims of 500,000+ American lives saved by the atomic bomb are usually not solely doubtful, however had been immediately opposite to the proof and estimates on the time. There have been varied invasion eventualities and, at worst, the American demise estimates didn’t even come near 500,000. A lot of this proof was unearthed by Gar Alperovitz in his Atomic Diplomacy (1965) and subsequent scholarship.
In June 1945, US navy planners estimated that, within the worst-case state of affairs, probably the most American deaths in an invasion plan amounted to 46,000. On June 15, 1945, the Joint Warfare Plans Committee (JWPC) projected estimates for 3 invasion eventualities—1) an assault on southern Kyushu, adopted by an assault on the Tokyo plain (40,000 lifeless); 2) an assault on southern Kyushu, adopted by northwestern Kyushu (25,000 lifeless); and, 3) an assault on southern Kyushu, adopted by northwestern Kyushu, after which the Tokyo plain (46,000 lifeless). Barton J. Bernstein concluded,
Clearly, all these estimates fell far brief—by at the very least 454,000—of later claims of 500,000 American lives. In actual fact, in early June 1945, when a layman advised a excessive quantity as a half one million lifeless, military planners bluntly replied in a secret report: “[such an] estimated loss…is completely too excessive.”
In personal writings quickly after Hiroshima and Nagasaki—and thus having little cause to magnify numbers—US navy leaders agreed that the declare of 500,000 American lives saved was completely too excessive. Not solely this, however Basic MacArhtur believed that the casualties and deaths wouldn’t be as excessive as the speed at Normandy and Okinawa (65,631 casualties; 7,374 deaths), in truth, he estimated that whole casualties can be properly underneath 100,000. This was communicated to the White Home by Basic Marshall. Even the extra pessimistic Admiral Leahy—mistakenly overstating Okinawa casualty estimates for reference—advised that the best estimate for casualties at Kyushu may be 230,000. Different estimates, based mostly on comparable historic paperwork, argue that “even within the worst case, [American lives saved] would have been within the vary of tens of 1000’s quite than tons of of 1000’s.”
The scholarly consensus now asserts that the struggle would have resulted in a comparatively brief time even with out the atomic bombs, that the choice invasions of Japan would have been unlikely, and that Truman and his advisers had been conscious of those choices. One other scholar, utilizing the information out there on the time, argues the outcomes of the unlikely worst case,
If this “worst-case state of affairs” had occurred—that’s, if the atomic bomb had not labored or had not been used, and if Japan had someway held out past November 1, 1945, and if the profitable invasion of southern Kyushu had been carried out, and if the Russians had entered the struggle in August (as they did) and engaged the Japanese in Manchuria and Korea, and if at that time the Japanese had surrendered—then an inexpensive estimate of American deaths virtually absolutely would have been no more than 20,000 and doubtless lower than 15,000 (5,000 for air and naval losses earlier than the invasion, no more than 10,000 throughout the invasion of Kyushu, and an added allowance of 5,000 for unexpected losses). (emphasis added)
However, whereas it’s tough to backwards venture a counterfactual historical past that didn’t occur, the reality stays that, “When Truman accepted the order of July 24 to make use of atomic bombs, he had by no means acquired a high-level report suggesting half one million or perhaps a quarter one million U.S. lifeless.” No US navy planner between Might 1945 and the interval following the bombings would have put the variety of American lives saved anyplace close to that top. To put it succinctly, “The parable of 500,000 [let alone millions of] American lives saved thus appears to don’t have any foundation in truth.”
Turn out to be a 2025 Member!
