miriam-doerr/iStock through Getty Photographs
It’s been a short while since I’ve lined FirstCash (FCFS), and fairly a bit has occurred since then, together with proof (eventually) of a robust restoration within the U.S. pawn market, a extra disappointingly sluggish restoration in Mexico, and a significant acquisition (American First Finance, or AFF) and entry into new markets (lease-to-own and different credit score merchandise).
To be trustworthy, I’m by no means bought on the AFF deal. I can see the enchantment, however I feel the capital may have gone to increasing the Latin American pawn operations in international locations like Colombia and Peru. That stated, it does provide one other potential supply of development and money move and diversifies the enterprise considerably (solely “considerably” given related clientele).
FirstCash shares are down barely since my final replace, and at this level, I consider the shares are priced to generate a gorgeous long-term double-digit annualized whole return. That stated, I’d suppose that the Road may want a bit time to get comfy with AFF and, likewise, might wish to see indicators of a stronger restoration in Mexico earlier than actually bidding the shares up once more.
Wholesome Underlying Outcomes In A Muddled Quarter
Due to the inclusion of a little bit of AFF income and earnings within the outcomes, FirstCash’s outcomes are very tough to check to prior sell-side common estimates. The place there are comparisons to be made, FirstCash’s underlying efficiency within the pawn enterprise was considerably higher than anticipated, although definitely combined between the U.S. and LatAm operations.
Income rose 28% within the quarter, with retail income up 28% and pawn charge income up 13%. Scrap income declined 40%, whereas AFF made a partial debut within the quarter, contributing $34M of an adjusted $502M in lower than a month of FirstCash’s possession.
Retail income beat expectations by round 13%, helped by sturdy ongoing efficiency within the U.S. enterprise, the place whole gross sales elevated 29% and 24% on a same-store foundation. In Latin America, development was additionally fairly sturdy, at 26% general and 24% same-store (each in fixed foreign money phrases). Whereas retail margins are easing off document highs, they’re nonetheless staying greater for longer than anticipated, with U.S. margin down about two factors to 43.1% and LatAm down two factors to 36%.
Core pawn charge income rose 13%, lacking by about 7%. U.S. charges rose 15% general and 10% on a same-store foundation, whereas LatAm charges rose 12% general and 11% on a same-store foundation. My sense is that the majority analysts had been anticipating stronger outcomes from LatAm (I used to be in my mannequin…), however pawn demand is lagging on a mixture of a much less dramatic restoration in Mexico and considerably elevated remittances to Mexico from the USA.
What considerations me extra, actually, is the tempo of pawn mortgage development, as this finally drives pawn charges. The U.S. stays sturdy, with 13% same-store development, however LatAm grew simply 6%.
pre-tax phase earnings, the U.S. pawn enterprise grew 43%, with margin up 330bp to 23.9%, whereas the LatAm pawn enterprise grew 20%, with margin up a couple of level to 21.7%. AFF debuted with an adjusted margin of 17.3%.
Pawn Demand Ought to Proceed To Get well, However Mexico Is A Concern
I’m comparatively bullish on the near-term outlook for pawn mortgage demand within the U.S. operations. Whereas the employment state of affairs is powerful, inflation may assist stimulate demand if and when wages don’t preserve tempo. Furthermore, given adjustments to tax objects just like the little one tax credit score, I consider there may very well be much less of a adverse affect to FirstCash this 12 months, with prospects/potential prospects getting decrease than anticipated refunds due to how these credit had been modified.
Within the LatAm operations, I’m nonetheless bullish on restoration prospects in Mexico, however the restoration has been sluggish to date and the elections this 12 months may create some turbulence. Whereas general pawn mortgage balances aren’t that worrying in comparison with pre-pandemic ranges, there’s positively been a slowdown right here, and FirstCash actually must reestablish the expansion credentials of the LatAm operations (the Mexican operations, specifically) – significantly as I feel some bears will argue that the acquisition of AFF was accomplished to masks/compensate for decrease anticipated development from LatAm pawn within the coming years.
AFF Makes Some Sense, However Carries New Dangers
Shopping for AFF provides FirstCash a digital-based client finance enterprise centered totally on lease-to-own (related in some respects to rent-to-own operations like Hire-A-Heart (RCII)), retail installment financing, and financial institution lending to an analogous buyer base (i.e., prospects that can’t simply entry conventional sources of credit score).
Paying round 10x ahead EBITDA for a enterprise with stable mid-teens EBITDA margins isn’t too dangerous, however AFF does convey dangers. First, whereas AFF operations aren’t lined by the CFPB, they’re regulated on the state degree and that brings some dangers again into the story that the corporate left behind when it exited payday lending.
Second, it’s a unique kind of enterprise and that at all times carries dangers, even with the present operations largely left in place. FirstCash amply demonstrated through the years that they perceive the pawn enterprise, however it stays to be seen how they fare within the point-of-sale financing enterprise, significantly with this house attracting much more consideration and aggressive entry of late.
Price synergies received’t be any actual issue right here, however there may very well be some operational synergies down the street. Surrendered merchandise from AFF’s leasing operations can go to FirstCash pawn shops, increasing their assortment, and AFF’s financing providers can be utilized to fund in-store retail purchases at FirstCash shops, doubtlessly opening the door to the sale of higher-ticket objects to a wider buyer base.
I additionally do like the truth that AFF makes use of a capital-light mannequin – AFF doesn’t personal and inventory shops, however as an alternative companions with retailers to supply their providers. I do know {that a} substantial quantity of AFF’s enterprise relies in furnishings (they usually do enterprise with 10 of the 50 largest furnishings retailers), however inputting my previous zip codes into their service provider accomplice database turns up lots of jewellery shops and auto service shops, so I just like the angle right here of AFF funding providers like auto repairs.
The Outlook
Including AFF into the mannequin definitely provides to the modeling threat, however the enterprise ought to see general demand developments roughly just like that of FirstCash. Given the quantity of recent entrants into POS financing, I’m reluctant to imagine that AFF will meaningfully enhance FirstCash’s long-term natural development price, however it does at the least broaden the bottom of enterprise. On the identical time, although, I admit to being extra involved concerning the development trajectory of the LatAm operations and the query of why administration isn’t placing extra capital into rising geographies like Colombia and Peru.
I’m modeling round 7% long-term income development utilizing my 2021 estimate as the start line (to neutralize the inorganic enhance from AFF). I’ve modestly trimmed again my longer-term margin assumptions, totally on considerations about LatAm and conservatism with my preliminary expectations for the AFF enterprise. Even so, I’m searching for long-term adjusted FCF margins within the low double-digits and development within the excessive single-digits. I’ve additionally elevated my low cost price to account for greater threat – extra debt, slower development in LatAm, and the dangers of coming into a brand new enterprise line.
The Backside Line
I just like the prospects for a robust restoration within the core pawn enterprise, together with the potential for higher-for-longer retail margins, and whereas I’m extra involved concerning the LatAm operations, I nonetheless see them as a development driver. With AFF, I’d describe my emotions as extra “guardedly optimistic”; administration has earned the advantage of the doubt, however I might want to see some proof that this was a greater use of capital than increasing the ex-Mexico LatAm pawn operations. Working my new estimates via my valuation mannequin, I nonetheless get a considerably greater honest worth than right now’s value, and I consider FirstCash is priced for double-digit long-term annualized returns.
