Sunday, August 24, 2025
  • Login
Euro Times
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Finance
  • Business
  • World
  • Politics
  • Markets
  • Stock Market
  • Cryptocurrency
  • Investing
  • Health
  • Technology
  • Home
  • Finance
  • Business
  • World
  • Politics
  • Markets
  • Stock Market
  • Cryptocurrency
  • Investing
  • Health
  • Technology
Euro Times
No Result
View All Result

Is It Finally Time to Sell Protolabs Stock?

by Nanalyze
November 11, 2022
in Markets
Reading Time: 11 mins read
A A
0
Home Markets
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter


Deciding to buy a stock is easy. We spend a minimal amount of time convincing ourselves that it’s worth the risk while conducting due diligence that would hardly be considered sufficient. If 95% of professional money managers can’t succeed at stock picking, spending several hours in your underwear on a Saturday morning “researching” a stock while trying to avoid the temptation of YouTube isn’t going to cut it. It’s precisely why everyone wants someone else to take responsibility for their investment decisions. Still, you pull the trigger and ideally accumulate a position using dollar cost averaging. If the share price goes up, you attribute that to your tremendous investing acumen. If it falls, you panic and start consulting with The Ministry of Truth.

Credit: The Ministry of Truth

The tough part is deciding when to sell a stock. Our portfolio cap weighting rule helps trim the winners as we did with Nvidia (in 2021 alone, we recovered our cost basis more than seven times over), while our tremendous investing acumen helped us reap the rewards when gene editing stocks hit the moon because of hype. (Regular readers know that our secret weapon for generating alpha is the Romanian fortune teller we hired on Fiver who made that freaking amazing Ali Baba call.) But figuring out when to sell stocks you’re holding at a loss can be one of the toughest decisions to make.

When to Sell a Tech Stock

You can argue about whether paper losses are actual losses, but there’s no debate that you solidify those losses when selling shares. We’ve sold stocks at a loss several times over the years with some examples seen below (company names link to past research pieces).

  Sold Date Reason Fall Since
Ocado 10/18/2021 Too much UK grocery exposure 73%
Appen 12/28/2020 Business model problems 90%
Berkeley Lights 9/15/2021 Short report + own suspicions 92%
Credit: Nanalyze

In each of the above cases, the stocks went on to lose significantly more once we exited our positions, but that doesn’t mean we made the right decision. The stock market has a way of humbling those who brag about how great their trades are. Even with these sharp drops in value seen above, it’s too early to tell if we ultimately made the right decision. Only when a stock ceases trading on a major market can we then compare our cost basis to the value the business ended up realizing.

In all cases seen above, we exited rather quickly as opposed to “reverse dollar cost averaging.” The first two names – Ocado and Appen – traded on foreign exchanges which charged commission fees, so we just went at it in one swell foop. The third – Berkeley Lights – was under lots of selling pressure so we exited the position abruptly. Today, we want to talk about another stock we might be exiting – Protolabs (PRLB).

Protolabs Stock Plunges

Price action should never come into play when you decide to sell a stock. When Protolabs fell 30% last week, we knew earnings had come out, and that the news wasn’t good. While the company met their guidance for Q3-2022, they noted that “revenue from injection molding parts has underperformed expectations in the first three quarters of 2022.” That’s their highest margin offering which makes up nearly half of their business.

Credit: Protolabs

Says the company, “injection molding is one of our higher margin services, and with lower volume, it becomes challenging to absorb fixed costs and overhead.” So not only has growth stalled, but profitability is becoming increasingly difficult to come by as seen in Protolabs’ quarterly earnings.

Credit: Nanalyze

As growth investors, we don’t care about positive earnings, we mainly look at revenue growth as a proxy for market disruption. Protolabs doesn’t have that either, a concern we raised in a recent piece titled, Protolabs Stock: Where’s the Revenue Growth?

Vanishing Revenue Goals

This is what Protolabs used to look like back when we were ogling them as a potential leader in the distributed manufacturing space just over three years ago.

Credit: Protolabs

And this is what happened to that growth over the past four years – a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 1.33% which doesn’t even beat inflation. (The below chart uses the midpoint guidance Protolabs gave for Q4-2022 of $11 million).

One argument would be to give the company additional time to realize the promised revenue growth, but their ambitious goals have all but disappeared. The 112-page investor deck we analyzed almost exactly a year ago made multiple mentions of an internal Protolabs roadmap that expected revenues to double over the next five years – $1 billion by 2026.

Credit: Protolabs

With growth apparently stalled, we emailed the company’s investor relations team asking if the company could comment on their ability to hit this revenue target given the bear market in last week’s earnings call. Radio silence, but a new investor deck published last week is void of any reference to doubling revenues by a particular year. Instead, we’re given a spiel about how much “impact” they’re having, a shout out to the ESG police with their opaque methodologies that all differ in methods and performance.

The fall in share price of around 30% wasn’t for obvious reasons. Protolabs met their guidance, but softened Q4-2022 guidance leading to declining year-over-year growth at the midpoint. Analysts probed as to how much of the slowing growth might be from “additional competitive share loss,” and challenged management as to why the stagnating revenue segment – injection molding – was previously being touted as “very defensible in nature.” Protolabs responded by saying their sales team would be more aggressive, but shouldn’t the service offering be selling itself based on cost and flexibility?

When we see times of big supply chain shocks, we do very well because of our ability to be responsive.

Protolabs Q3-2022 Earnings Call

Maybe Xometry has been seeing those benefits, but certainly not Protolabs.

Selling Protolabs Stock

There’s something to be said about waiting this one out and hoping that some private equity firm steps in to acquire the distressed assets on offer, but we need to stand by our principles. This is a management team that blew the “$1 billion by 2026” trumpet for several years before suddenly going quiet. The new investor deck published just days ago makes no mention of that seemingly forgotten goal. Our email to the investor relations team fell on deaf ears which is precisely why we hardly ever reach out to companies we cover. While it’s never fun to lock in losses, we don’t have faith in management’s ability to grow revenues, and with margins getting squeezed, it’s only a matter of time before they’ll need to raise more capital in todays’ bear market by taking on debt or selling shares at depressed prices.

Analysts on the latest earnings call alluded to the fact that it may be more than just economic headwinds creating problems for Protolabs. Perhaps the competition is doing some damage, an observation we made before in the below chart which compares Protolabs’ revenue growth to Xometry’s (Xometry’s Q3-2022 revenue number seen below is a company guidance estimate).

Credit: Nanalyze

Protolabs is looking more like a large machine shop that customers need to be convinced to use. Contrast their stalled revenue growth with the software business model of Xometry (XMTR) and it seems as if the business model critics were right.

Conclusion

For tech companies, a proxy for disruption is revenue growth which represents the percentage of total addressable market being captured. In the absence of revenue growth, there’s no disruption happening. Management teams need to be held accountable for making and breaking goals. Should we decide to exit our position in Protolabs, Nanalyze Premium subscribers will be the first to know.

Tech investing is extremely risky. Minimize your risk with our stock research, investment tools, and portfolios, and find out which tech stocks you should avoid. Become a Nanalyze Premium member and find out today!



Source link

Tags: finallyProtolabsSellStocktime
Previous Post

Seven-Figure Flips and Opportunity Zone Investing

Next Post

Bitcoin miners ‘next trigger’ for BTC price crash as outflows hit multi-month highs

Related Posts

Medtronic makes two key additions to its board. How activist Elliott can build shareholder value

Medtronic makes two key additions to its board. How activist Elliott can build shareholder value

by Kenneth Squire
August 23, 2025
0

Michael Siluk | Training Photos | Common Photos Group | Getty PhotosFirm: Medtronic PLC (MDT)Enterprise: Medtronic PLC is an Eire-based...

9 Effective Ways to Keep Mulch in Place

9 Effective Ways to Keep Mulch in Place

by Kristin Kurens
August 23, 2025
0

Ozgur Coskun / Shutterstock.comYou may cease stressing over runaway mulch now. Irrespective of the climate or slope, preserve mulch in...

Earnings Preview: Alibaba (BABA) likely to report mixed results for Q1 2026

Earnings Preview: Alibaba (BABA) likely to report mixed results for Q1 2026

by Staff Correspondent
August 24, 2025
0

Alibaba Group Holding Restricted (NYSE: BABA) is navigating a posh panorama marked by restructuring efforts, AI-driven progress, and lingering fallout...

Is AI Security Helping or Harming America’s Schools?

Is AI Security Helping or Harming America’s Schools?

by Ian King
August 24, 2025
0

I went to an all-boys highschool — Christian Brothers Academy — the place the closest factor we needed to a...

FREE Baby Stuff for Parents: 15+ Free Baby Items, Samples, Boxes, and more!

FREE Baby Stuff for Parents: 15+ Free Baby Items, Samples, Boxes, and more!

by Crystal Paine
July 6, 2025
0

Don’t miss this large checklist of free child stuff: 15+ free child gadgets, samples, child registry bins, and extra! Profiting...

How Trump tariffs may affect debt repayment: survey

How Trump tariffs may affect debt repayment: survey

by Ana Teresa Solá
July 6, 2025
0

Studio4 | E+ | Getty PhotographsAs President Donald Trump continues to barter the speed of tariffs that international locations will...

Next Post
Bitcoin miners ‘next trigger’ for BTC price crash as outflows hit multi-month highs

Bitcoin miners 'next trigger' for BTC price crash as outflows hit multi-month highs

Ind vs Eng Live Score, T20 World Cup 2022: Kohli survives close DRS call

Ind vs Eng Live Score, T20 World Cup 2022: Kohli survives close DRS call

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Chinese airlines apply for slots at Delhi, initiate steps to resume flights

Chinese airlines apply for slots at Delhi, initiate steps to resume flights

August 24, 2025
Israeli military targets Yemen’s Sanaa after Houthi attacks | Israel-Palestine conflict News

Israeli military targets Yemen’s Sanaa after Houthi attacks | Israel-Palestine conflict News

August 24, 2025
Walker And Dunlop Tries To Stay Healthy In A Struggling Market (NYSE:WD)

Walker And Dunlop Tries To Stay Healthy In A Struggling Market (NYSE:WD)

August 24, 2025
I couldn’t find an ideal pet app, so I used Notion instead

I couldn’t find an ideal pet app, so I used Notion instead

August 24, 2025
Best money market account rates today, August 24, 2025 (best account provides 4.41% APY)

Best money market account rates today, August 24, 2025 (best account provides 4.41% APY)

August 24, 2025
Why the Donbas Is the Key to the Ukraine War

Why the Donbas Is the Key to the Ukraine War

August 24, 2025
Euro Times

Get the latest news and follow the coverage of Business & Financial News, Stock Market Updates, Analysis, and more from the trusted sources.

CATEGORIES

  • Business
  • Cryptocurrency
  • Finance
  • Health
  • Investing
  • Markets
  • Politics
  • Stock Market
  • Technology
  • Uncategorized
  • World

LATEST UPDATES

Chinese airlines apply for slots at Delhi, initiate steps to resume flights

Israeli military targets Yemen’s Sanaa after Houthi attacks | Israel-Palestine conflict News

  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • DMCA
  • Cookie Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Contact us

Copyright © 2022 - Euro Times.
Euro Times is not responsible for the content of external sites.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Finance
  • Business
  • World
  • Politics
  • Markets
  • Stock Market
  • Cryptocurrency
  • Investing
  • Health
  • Technology

Copyright © 2022 - Euro Times.
Euro Times is not responsible for the content of external sites.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In