Serving to my member of the family get a “free” 4G telephone from T-Cell was surprisingly sophisticated, particularly with the wi-fi provider making very clear that its 3G community was retiring in weeks. They did obtain a textual content message stating they have been eligible for a brand new 4G-compatible OnePlus telephone — however not like different carriers which might be handing out free 4G telephones — T-Cell required a trade-in of a tool that was in good situation.
That requirement is what made it troublesome. My member of the family has been utilizing an iPhone 5S first bought in 2014, and the telephone’s display screen is steadily separating itself from the remainder of the telephone’s physique. This iPhone 5S was initially bought for Verizon and wasn’t suitable with T-Cell’s LTE community. The telephone is in any other case not often used, as this member of the family prefers to make use of an iPad at dwelling so we have now them on a really low cost $3-per-month pay as you go plan.
Ought to I try to commerce within the clearly broken iPhone? Ought to we dig out another functioning telephone and commerce that in? And since we’re in the end paying for service, what occurs if we won’t get this member of the family a brand new gadget forward of the 3G shutdown?
These problems led me to marvel wider than simply this T-Cell expertise, and I reached out to the three main carriers, T-Cell, Verizon and AT&T, to learn the way these carriers are helping clients who may have extra time earlier than shifting to a more moderen telephone.
The 3G networks for T-Cell, Dash and AT&T have been retired, and Verizon’s is subsequent.
Angela Lang/CNET
Ending 3G networks could be a good factor
Whereas the shutdown of 3G networks does disconnect older telephones and gadgets from entry to mobile networks, it does create a number of alternatives to enhance telephone performance throughout fundamental telephones and smartphones.
Anshel Sag, a mobility analyst from Moor Insights and Technique, famous that shifting clients away from these much less safe gadgets additionally strikes them towards higher calling experiences like higher-quality voice-over-LTE audio calls.
“I do suppose the buyer ought to have a sure stage of alternative however on the similar time the straggling customers can change into a burden on the remainder of the person base when it comes to entry to new providers,” Sag stated. These enhanced VoLTE calls, for example, at the moment are obtainable throughout each smartphones and 4G-capable fundamental telephones.
And though Verizon, T-Cell and AT&T are overtly creating their 5G networks, clients who transfer to 4G-only gadgets needn’t fear about being compelled onto one other telephone within the close to future. Sag estimated that 4G LTE networks have loads of life to go.
“We’re most likely one other 10 years till the 4G shutdown,” Sag stated. He famous that radio waves beforehand used for 3G also can change to enhance quicker 5G networks because the carriers work to enhance their protection.
Whereas Sag famous there’s all the time going to be a proportion of shoppers who select to not transfer to a more moderen gadget, he stated that it stays within the carriers’ finest curiosity to both assist provide new gadgets or to cease billing.
“These clients are legacy clients that they’ve had a really very long time as a perform of how lengthy 3G has been round,” Sag stated.

T-Cell’s 3G community is retired, however its 2G community remains to be energetic.
James Martin/CNET
T-Cell (and Dash’s) community shutdown
T-Cell is the latest provider to retire its 3G networks, having turned off its 3G UMTS community on July 1. Along with that community, T-Cell additionally sundown Dash’s 3G community on March 31. T-Cell does nonetheless have an older 2G community that’s slated for retirement, however no clear dates have been given simply but.
A T-Cell spokesperson stated that affected clients have been notified and are nonetheless eligible for a free substitute gadget by buying and selling of their older 3G telephone.
“Prospects with 3G-dependent telephones who haven’t but taken motion to improve are nonetheless eligible to obtain a free substitute by buying and selling of their older 3G gadget. The overwhelming majority of these with UMTS gadgets who haven’t but upgraded are coated by T-Cell’s 2G GSM community and proceed to obtain service,” the spokesperson stated.
T-Cell additionally pointed us to its community evolution buyer help web page, which matches into additional depth about efforts to achieve clients and the dates that every earlier community reached retirement.

AT&T’s 3G community sundown in February.
James Martin/CNET
AT&T has stopped charging clients who have not upgraded
AT&T’s 3G community was shuttered on Feb. 22. Within the lead as much as the shutdown, the provider posted on its help web page that affected clients have been contacted and will have obtained free telephones or SIM playing cards within the mail to be able to keep their protection.
Within the occasion an AT&T buyer did not activate a 4G-compatible gadget, they’ll not be charged for service.
“If a buyer’s billing cycle ended after the 3G service closing date, we supplied a credit score and they won’t obtain further payments,” AT&T stated in an announcement to CNET.

Verizon’s 3G community shuts down on the finish of 2022.
Sarah Tew/CNET
Verizon’s shutdown can be final, and there is time to get a free telephone
Verizon’s 3G community will flip off on Dec. 31, leaving months of time for patrons to maneuver to a tool that’s suitable with no less than its 4G LTE community.
Verizon is within the strategy of sending out free 4G-capable telephones to affected clients, which can be older flip telephones made by TCL, Nokia and Orbic. The gadgets do not require any trade-in and are being proactively despatched. Prospects who don’t need considered one of these telephones can name customer support to say no the provide.
Ought to a buyer determine that they do not need to transfer their service onto a 4G gadget, Verizon will cease charging as soon as the 3G community is shut down.
“If a buyer decides to remain on the 3G gadget (regardless of additional urging by name brokers or retail reps), then that gadget would cease working at sundown. The client wouldn’t be billed as soon as they’re disconnected from the community,” a Verizon rep stated in an e mail to CNET.
In case you want extra time to change telephones, you possibly can nonetheless use your telephone to backup necessary knowledge
After 3G networks are fully turned off, the telephone you may have will not be fully ineffective. Whereas it could possibly’t hook up with mobile knowledge, you would possibly nonetheless have restricted entry to options over Wi-Fi akin to entry to your contacts and Wi-Fi calling, the place it is supported.
Whereas precise processes will differ relying on whether or not you’re utilizing a 3G-only smartphone or fundamental telephone, you need to be capable of be certain your necessary contacts, calendars and notes that reside on the telephone are backed as much as one other service or saved to allow them to be loaded into one other gadget later.
Many 3G telephones are probably not receiving safety updates, and so whereas the gadget would possibly work it’s vital to ensure that it is not the one place the place necessary info is saved.

A retired 2016 iPhone SE (much like the mannequin seen right here on the left, paired with an iPhone 8) was capable of repair my household’s 3G transition.
César Salza/CNET
Fixing my household’s transition with out assist from T-Cell
Returning to my member of the family’s 3G transition, I made a decision to convey each the broken iPhone 5S and a long-retired 2014 Moto E as a backup to T-Cell’s retailer. Each telephones have been denied, and after we requested the consultant about different choices, he instructed me he could not say something.
The expertise was understandably disappointing and appeared to go away us with just some weeks to determine whether or not it would be worthwhile to purchase a telephone that we knew would solely be sparingly used.
We in the end resolved this by discovering one other member of the family’s retired iPhone SE and swapping the SIM card to that, however the expertise made it fairly apparent that one other household won’t be capable of simply luck out upon a brand new handset.
T-Cell’s spokesperson instructed me that the shop’s denial is not the provider’s coverage, apologized for that have and provided to resolve the difficulty by way of its Buyer Care group.